Executive Compensation Consulting
EXECUTIVE COMPENSATION FOR EQUITABLE, COMPETITIVE NONPROFIT LEADERSHIP
Our Executive Compensation service helps nonprofit boards and key decision-makers design CEO, Executive Director, and senior leadership compensation that is equitable, competitive, and aligned with your mission and values. We partner with boards, compensation committees, and executive teams to move beyond ad hoc or legacy pay decisions toward a clear, data-informed executive compensation program that stands up to scrutiny from staff, funders, and regulators.
Using a structured approach—context building, market analysis, and implementation support—we ground your executive pay decisions in robust benchmarking data, internal equity, financial sustainability, and the realities of your talent market. We analyze compensation for your executive roles across multiple sources, build market-aligned salary ranges and total cash recommendations, and help you codify principles that connect pay to performance, scope, and values. Throughout, we center Edgility’s pillars of equity—Clarity & Transparency, Fairness & Consistency, and Inclusion & Belonging—so your executive compensation structure is not only compliant and competitive, but also understandable and trusted across your organization.
As a female-founded, equity-centered firm with deep nonprofit and education experience, we understand the tension between attracting and retaining exceptional executives and honoring your commitments to equity and community. We show up as thought partners, offering unbiased, third-party guidance and an agile, partnership-based process that helps you operationalize your values in executive pay while managing risk and reputation.
WHO WE PARTNER WITH ON EXECUTIVE COMPENSATION
- Boards, board chairs, and board-level committees (compensation, finance, or executive) who are responsible for setting and reviewing CEO/ED and senior executive compensation.
- Executive Directors/CEOs and Heads of School who need a clear, values-aligned framework for how their own compensation and their teams’ compensation will be assessed and adjusted over time.
- Finance and talent leaders who must balance internal equity, external competitiveness, budget constraints, and compliance, and who need a consistent, defensible structure to guide recommendations.
We treat this work as a true partnership—aligning board and executive perspectives, bringing data and context to complex conversations, and building an executive compensation approach that your board can explain with confidence and integrity.
Our Process for Executive Compensation Design
1
CONTEXT BUILDING
We meet with board and executive leaders, review organizational context and current executive pay, and define the relevant labor market and peer set in partnership with you.
2
MARKET ANALYSIS
We conduct a robust quantitative benchmarking analysis across multiple data sources to assess how competitive and equitable your executive compensation is and develop salary ranges and total cash recommendations.
3
IMPLEMENTATION SUPPORT
We deliver a clear executive compensation report and provide targeted coaching for board and executive leaders so you can adopt, communicate, and sustain the new executive compensation program with clarity, fairness, and financial responsibility.
Omar Carrera
CEO
Danielle Pointdujour
Human Resources Officer, Urgent Action Fund
Willa Marth
Chief Diversity and Inclusion Officer, Planned Parenthood of Southern New England
While Planned Parenthood of Southern New England (PPSNE) has worked to increase racial equity internally and externally, the racial reckoning of 2020 illuminated the need to ask ourselves what more we can do. With Edgility's methodology, we had clear data points and recommendations to create a plan internally to address any wage gaps and further our commitment to racial equity.
Sonia Dominguez
Chief Operating Officer, AVANCE
Erica Kashiri
Chief Operating Officer, Third Plateau
Deena Mangrum
Director of Talent Strategy, Para Los Niños
Catrina Bryant
Deputy Director, Arnold and Mabel Beckman Foundation
J.J. Lewis
Superintendent & CEO, Compass Charter Schools
Illy Askia
President & CEO, East Lake Foundation
Alicia Spurlark
Director of Operations
Other Services Our Clients Often Explore
Empowering Organizations Through Holistic Talent Management
Organizations that invest in comprehensive talent management experience lower turnover, higher employee engagement, stronger teams, and improved overall performance. Effective talent strategies are essential for organizations aiming to achieve meaningful impact and advance their mission. Here's where we stand.
97%
CLIENT SATISFACTION RATE
Our clients appreciate our team's dedication to delivering exceptional service and exceeding their expectations every step of the way.
93
NET PROMOTER SCORE
We outperform the industry average net promoter score of 48 by more than 65%—demonstrating our commitment to customer happiness.
100%
WOULD WORK WITH EDGILITY AGAIN
And many of them do! Over three-quarters of our clients have worked with us more than once or came from a client's recommendation.

